There are many who react to the church shooting at Charleston’s historic Emanuel A.M.R. Church by blaming availability of guns and decrying racism.
But one thing missing from the discussion, that is a victimhood mentality and the idea that all people of a particular race are guilty because of the acts of a few.
When Dylann Storm Roof walked into the doors of that church he was armed with two ideas: 1) his tribe (white people, women, etc) were the victims, and 2) their tribe (black people) were collectively responsible for black rapists, perceived injustice, etc.
It was the ideas that this depraved young man harbored in his heart that were dangerous. However, these ideas are not unique to him or just to unreasonable and angry white men. These are ideas accepted accepted in mainstream thought that divides people into falsely dichotomous categories.
Who kills the innocent? We do!
Ideas that white is equal to privilege or black is equal to victimhood are equally dangerous. When we feed the martyr complex and victimhood mentality we are giving license to those of an even more deranged mind to take it a step further.
The problem with Roof and those like him (of all races, genders, etc) is not what they do—but that they feel justified to do it. We can fret about availability of guns and a multitude of other factors, but until we address the heart issue we are only treating the symptoms.
We won’t stop a person bent on evil and destruction with more legislation. If anything more law will only create the next inequity and give some other person reason to feel disenfranchised. But what we do need is to unravel the false dichotomies and prejudice assumptions that fuel hatred.
Being on the ‘right’ side of history…
We are urged to be on the “right side of history” yet the problem is that everyone (including Roof) feels they are on the ‘right’ side and justified. Jesus encountered this in the Pharisees who thought themselves better than other people and superior to their own ancestors:
“Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You build tombs for the prophets and decorate the graves of the righteous. And you say, ‘If we had lived in the days of our ancestors, we would not have taken part with them in shedding the blood of the prophets.’ So you testify against yourselves that you are the descendants of those who murdered the prophets.” (Matthew 23:29-31)
There are many sanctimonious today who think they are superior to other people. They may decry the injustices of the past, support punishment for those they hold responsible and blame, but they themselves often as guilty or more of similar abuse.
Is an anti-abortion activist who calls women entering a clinic names or murderers a provider any better than those they accuse?
Is a person who labels others as “racist” or “homophobic” or “hateful” in response to a disagreement over opinion less abusive than a person who uses the n-word?
I say, no and no.
The solution to hate is not to be hateful. As Mahatma Gandhi wisely observed: “An eye for an an eye only leaves the whole world blind.” What he observed is the same as when Jesus quipped that those who live by the sword will die by it (Matthew 26:52) or ‘what goes around comes around’ in essence.
We make a difference by being different…
Everyone has reason for their own abuses. Many of the most abusive people in history believed they served a righteous cause. Many people can identify the sins of other tribes or the prior generation, but few seem able to see their own abuses. We prefer to keep the spotlight on those whom we perceive to be worse than us than we are interested in searching out the wickedness of our own hearts.
Ben Carson spoke well:
“You know, we have a war on women, race wars, income wars, age wars, religious wars. Anything you could imagine, we have a war on it… And we’re giving people a license to hate people who disagree with them.”
We need to stop arming ourselves with contempt and be committed to loving as we wish to be loved. It is easy to love our own and hate others, but divine love seeks unity rather than encourage division. It sacrifices self rather than perpetuate cycles of violence. It brings grace to the fight even when vengeance feels justified.
Grace saves us…
It is the Spirit of love like that of Marcus Stanley, who was shot eight times but lived, and chose grace in response to hate:
“I don’t look at you with the eyes of hatred, or judge you by your appearance or race, but I look at you as a human being that made a horrible decision to take the lives of 9 living & breathing people. Children do not grow up with hatred in their hearts. In this world we are born color blind. Somewhere along the line, you were taught to hate people that are not like you, and that is truly tragic. You have accomplished nothing from this killing, but planting seeds of pain that will forever remain in the hearts of the families that lost their lives and countless hearts around our country.”
Let’s not fall victim to those who would divide us into categories, but instead seek the unity of all people only possible with a love that tears down walls, bridges divides and believes when others say it is impossible.
May those seeds of Roof’s hate stay dead and the love of Jesus in Stanley’s gracious response grow in us. The answer is not more or less guns nor petitions against flags and protest, it is less hate and more Jesus.
“Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.” (Romans 12:21)